The Latest from the Australian Mobile Electronics Industry Since 1999 60,000+ Readers Per Month! Get the MEA iPhone App

Jump to content


More speaker confusion.. Middle range 3 way or high end 2 way?


16 replies to this topic

#1 blue_6006

    25 - 250w RMS

  • Members
  • 205 posts
  • State:WA

Posted 23 February 2010 - 01:28 AM

Hi peoples.

Whilst the installation costs of a 3 way speaker set initially put me of, I cannot help thinking it is the next best step I can make.
So.. I thought instead of getting a relatively high end 3 way set like the focal 165KRX3, I could go for the Polyglass 165VR3. I have had Polyglass before and was very happy so I have no issues with getting them again.

However - here is the question..
Do I get a high end 2 way set like KRX2 or Dyn 242GT and install them myself or get a middle range 3 way set like the 165VR3s and get them installed pro?

Either way the splits will be run from the passive XO from a Focal FP2.150 so I have 150WRMS to play with.

For me, the polyglass are proven.. However their only shortfall was they were a tad harsh so I ended up replacing the tweeters with some old Kevlar TN42's which made a nice difference.

Also, the car is a 2004 WRX STi and I would like to put the mid and the tweeter in the kick panel.

Let me know what you all think..

Thanks,

Emille

#2 Gonadman2

    Comic Book Hero

  • Members
  • 2,100 posts
  • Gender:Male
  • Location:Perth
  • State:WA

Posted 23 February 2010 - 02:08 AM

Go 3 way, pretty sure Juls has a similar setup in his work ute and he likes it.

#3 ~Spyne~

    SQN00B

  • Verified Trader
  • 9,661 posts
  • Gender:Male
  • State:VIC

Posted 23 February 2010 - 07:45 AM

if you're going to go the effort of 3-way, imo, you MUST get a set that uses a larger midbass than the standard 6.5"
something with an 8" or 9" woofer would be more my choice. or something with a high-excursion 7" like CSS or SS rev
just my opinion.

Posted Image


2008 National Champion - Intermediate Class
2009 State Champion - Intermediate Class
2010 State Champion - Advanced 1 Class

2011 State Champion - Advanced Class


MEASQ National Manager


#4 xMplar

    xMplar

  • Members
  • 1,834 posts
  • Gender:Male
  • Location:ON THE BLOCK MAN
  • Interests:Car Audio, Cars in general and Women, ALso women in cars playing with car audio and most ofg all BMWs always bemmers and women in beemers and car audio in bmws
  • State:WA

Posted 23 February 2010 - 11:32 AM

well first off i would get them done professionally and if you want a set of three way top of the range speakers i have a set of cheshendo 8.9 3ways doing nothing with a 3way xover for them id be willing to let go for a good price they are new never used we went a differnt way and didnt use them if you want to cvheck them out im in perth or give me a buzz check my details on here for my number

ill do you a good deal on them aswell and then you will have a top set of 3ways for a middle of the range price

and have enuf to get them put in by a pro

Ren
xMplar
<strong>E34 BMW 535is with M5 drive train gear box diff full custom interior leather trim and cstom doors backself and dash<br />Built motor waiting for the 4.4L 6speed V8 bmw engine with 700+ hp atw<br />HU:</strong>Eclipse 5030 <strong>front stage:</strong>1 x Audio System HX 165-4DUST duel midbass for a 3way duel mid front<br /><strong>front mid:</strong> a pair of HX100sq <br /><strong>front tweet:</strong> HX VOL 25 neo ferro fluid tweeter<br /><strong>Rear stage</strong> 1 x HX165 DUST and 1 x ad4 mid for a 3way rear<br /><strong>Front stage Amp: </strong>AUDIOSYSTEM MOSCONI 200.2 <br /><strong>Rear stage Amp:</strong> 1 x AUDIOSYSTEM MOSCNI 100.2 <br /><strong>Sub Amp:</strong> 2 x AUDIOSYSTEM MOSCONI 300.2 All amps in white and black<br /><strong>Subs:</strong>4 x 12&quot; Audio System HX PHASE range SQ Subs<br /><strong>Wireing:</strong> 0g 4g 8g 12g power ground and speaker cables Custom Made RCAS <br /><strong>Batts: </strong>1 x euro din size battery for starting<br /><strong>SECONDAY:,</strong> 1 x 200ah estoar battery <br /><strong>Sound Dead</strong>: 4 x Bulk packs of dynamatt roof floor all four doors boot boot lid firewall <br />2 layers in some places <br />Looking for more p80rs p88 rsand p90rs p9 p99rs etc good cond please and price

#5 ~Spyne~

    SQN00B

  • Verified Trader
  • 9,661 posts
  • Gender:Male
  • State:VIC

Posted 23 February 2010 - 12:15 PM

oooh, crescendo 3-way....yummy

Posted Image


2008 National Champion - Intermediate Class
2009 State Champion - Intermediate Class
2010 State Champion - Advanced 1 Class

2011 State Champion - Advanced Class


MEASQ National Manager


#6 xMplar

    xMplar

  • Members
  • 1,834 posts
  • Gender:Male
  • Location:ON THE BLOCK MAN
  • Interests:Car Audio, Cars in general and Women, ALso women in cars playing with car audio and most ofg all BMWs always bemmers and women in beemers and car audio in bmws
  • State:WA

Posted 23 February 2010 - 12:19 PM

yes yummy and they are up for grabs at a good price tooooo

Ren
xMplar
<strong>E34 BMW 535is with M5 drive train gear box diff full custom interior leather trim and cstom doors backself and dash<br />Built motor waiting for the 4.4L 6speed V8 bmw engine with 700+ hp atw<br />HU:</strong>Eclipse 5030 <strong>front stage:</strong>1 x Audio System HX 165-4DUST duel midbass for a 3way duel mid front<br /><strong>front mid:</strong> a pair of HX100sq <br /><strong>front tweet:</strong> HX VOL 25 neo ferro fluid tweeter<br /><strong>Rear stage</strong> 1 x HX165 DUST and 1 x ad4 mid for a 3way rear<br /><strong>Front stage Amp: </strong>AUDIOSYSTEM MOSCONI 200.2 <br /><strong>Rear stage Amp:</strong> 1 x AUDIOSYSTEM MOSCNI 100.2 <br /><strong>Sub Amp:</strong> 2 x AUDIOSYSTEM MOSCONI 300.2 All amps in white and black<br /><strong>Subs:</strong>4 x 12&quot; Audio System HX PHASE range SQ Subs<br /><strong>Wireing:</strong> 0g 4g 8g 12g power ground and speaker cables Custom Made RCAS <br /><strong>Batts: </strong>1 x euro din size battery for starting<br /><strong>SECONDAY:,</strong> 1 x 200ah estoar battery <br /><strong>Sound Dead</strong>: 4 x Bulk packs of dynamatt roof floor all four doors boot boot lid firewall <br />2 layers in some places <br />Looking for more p80rs p88 rsand p90rs p9 p99rs etc good cond please and price

#7 Chaos

    rockin' in the free world

  • Members
  • 714 posts
  • Gender:Male
  • Location:Canberra
  • Interests:Guitars, British rock and roll, cars, computers and university (not an interest!)
  • State:ACT

Posted 23 February 2010 - 12:23 PM

Ooh that would be tempting...
"So, my big brother was playing guitar and I figured I'd try it too." - Stevie Ray Vaughan

"Permission to say cock!"


Trusted Sellers: bagtho, Gozza, Chemhaz, KGB, meaty_taco, Ren (xMplar)

QUOTE (Big_Valven @ Jan 31 2010, 12:13 AM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
Far out Chaos, you're all over it like a bad smell tonight! keep up the good work :)

#8 hardyards

    500 - 1500w RMS

  • Members
  • 1,335 posts
  • Gender:Male
  • State:QLD

Posted 23 February 2010 - 04:44 PM

yes, if the mid would fit in my doors i would be very tempted!

#9 ~Samuel~

    Team XS Audio

  • Members
  • 5,311 posts
  • Gender:Male
  • Location:Adelaide Hills
  • Interests:Music
  • State:SA

Posted 25 February 2010 - 05:35 PM

Now that is typical SQ thinking, make them fit... :P

Posted Image


#10 hardyards

    500 - 1500w RMS

  • Members
  • 1,335 posts
  • Gender:Male
  • State:QLD

Posted 25 February 2010 - 06:38 PM

im an sq poser :P

plus im to soft to cut my car up :(























for now

#11 ardenteagle

    25 - 250w RMS

  • Members
  • 238 posts
  • Gender:Male
  • Location:Ballajura W.A
  • Interests:My wife, Music, Footy, Food, Beer, Friends, Car, Family - What more in life could you want!
  • State:WA

Posted 27 February 2010 - 04:33 PM

Hope they'll fit into Evo 8 doors because I'm going to be buying the Crescendo 3 ways to replace my ID XS65's, I'll be running them as 2 way until I can afford the amp upgrade/install for the full 3 way system. Its still going to be a huge improvement regardless.
01 Stagea Wagon VQ25DET, My Work/Play Vehicle






Front Stage - Hybrid Audio L6, L1 Pro SE ( Active )
Powered by - RF 851x Power




H/U - Pioneer DEH - P80RS




Sub - ID10D2V3
Powered by - Steg 240.1 Mono

#12 zion187reigneth

    General monkey

  • Members
  • 3,096 posts
  • Gender:Male
  • Location:Russia
  • Interests:DIrt bikes,Drag racing,General monkey business
  • State:Other

Posted 27 February 2010 - 10:46 PM

blue_6006, on Feb 23 2010, 01:28 AM, said:

Hi peoples.

Whilst the installation costs of a 3 way speaker set initially put me of, I cannot help thinking it is the next best step I can make.
So.. I thought instead of getting a relatively high end 3 way set like the focal 165KRX3, I could go for the Polyglass 165VR3. I have had Polyglass before and was very happy so I have no issues with getting them again.

However - here is the question..
Do I get a high end 2 way set like KRX2 or Dyn 242GT and install them myself or get a middle range 3 way set like the 165VR3s and get them installed pro?

Either way the splits will be run from the passive XO from a Focal FP2.150 so I have 150WRMS to play with.

For me, the polyglass are proven.. However their only shortfall was they were a tad harsh so I ended up replacing the tweeters with some old Kevlar TN42's which made a nice difference.

Also, the car is a 2004 WRX STi and I would like to put the mid and the tweeter in the kick panel.

Let me know what you all think..

Thanks,

Emille
I 2nd the bigger woofer 3way, but hey if your rear sub is perfect then it can do alot of the hz blend with your midbass anyway.

My history
1977 LX torana=Remove HU and speakers ~run quarter mile 12.68
Gorilla Nuts= deceased (all parts were removed)
no car sound at all.
The Irrepressible nature of install monkey's
http://s98.photobuck...nstall_monkeys/

Posted Image


#13 xMplar

    xMplar

  • Members
  • 1,834 posts
  • Gender:Male
  • Location:ON THE BLOCK MAN
  • Interests:Car Audio, Cars in general and Women, ALso women in cars playing with car audio and most ofg all BMWs always bemmers and women in beemers and car audio in bmws
  • State:WA

Posted 27 February 2010 - 11:14 PM

still to the op here if you ant a top set of 2ways i can helo you out or rvrn sa set of AD3ways made uop of AD60 woofer an ad4 mid and a t100tweet with a 3way xocer to go

with it they are truly amazing spakers if you ant them they would notmaslly be well over 1500 mark but illl let them go for a low low low price of well its just for you txt me or pm m for the deal as you missed the crshebndos the deal is simple man you buy the best you can afforf for th frontsd sd that were oyou listenin is odner the modt ok
<strong>E34 BMW 535is with M5 drive train gear box diff full custom interior leather trim and cstom doors backself and dash<br />Built motor waiting for the 4.4L 6speed V8 bmw engine with 700+ hp atw<br />HU:</strong>Eclipse 5030 <strong>front stage:</strong>1 x Audio System HX 165-4DUST duel midbass for a 3way duel mid front<br /><strong>front mid:</strong> a pair of HX100sq <br /><strong>front tweet:</strong> HX VOL 25 neo ferro fluid tweeter<br /><strong>Rear stage</strong> 1 x HX165 DUST and 1 x ad4 mid for a 3way rear<br /><strong>Front stage Amp: </strong>AUDIOSYSTEM MOSCONI 200.2 <br /><strong>Rear stage Amp:</strong> 1 x AUDIOSYSTEM MOSCNI 100.2 <br /><strong>Sub Amp:</strong> 2 x AUDIOSYSTEM MOSCONI 300.2 All amps in white and black<br /><strong>Subs:</strong>4 x 12&quot; Audio System HX PHASE range SQ Subs<br /><strong>Wireing:</strong> 0g 4g 8g 12g power ground and speaker cables Custom Made RCAS <br /><strong>Batts: </strong>1 x euro din size battery for starting<br /><strong>SECONDAY:,</strong> 1 x 200ah estoar battery <br /><strong>Sound Dead</strong>: 4 x Bulk packs of dynamatt roof floor all four doors boot boot lid firewall <br />2 layers in some places <br />Looking for more p80rs p88 rsand p90rs p9 p99rs etc good cond please and price

#14 br85

    500 - 1500w RMS

  • Members
  • 1,323 posts
  • Gender:Male
  • Location:Redlands City Shire,~Bris
  • State:QLD

Posted 27 February 2010 - 11:50 PM

xMplar, on Feb 27 2010, 11:14 PM, said:

th frontsd sd that were oyou listenin is odner the modt ok
Ok I know you're not good with punctuation, and sometimes you post drunk, but this little snippet needs some serious explanation.

tl;dr
"WHAT THE?"

ss-rotel, on 14 September 2010 - 11:05 PM, said:

you dont some much hear, but fell the sound

#15 sean

    MetalManiac

  • Members
  • 2,510 posts
  • Gender:Male
  • Location:Melb.
  • Interests:Electronics, Audio, Metalwork
  • State:VIC

Posted 28 February 2010 - 07:59 AM

Can't you translate easy stuff like that yet?! :P


it means:

" the deal is simple man, you buy the best you can afford for the fronts, they are the ones you are listening to the most, ok..."
Black Alfa Romeo 164 Q: Denon DCT-Z1, Zapco 1000.1,
Sinfoni 90.2 (2x), Sinfoni 45.2x, Scanspeak AirCirc tweeters,

Focal Be 3W2 Midrange, Focal Be 6W2 Midbass,(2x) PHD AF10W subwoofers


______________________________________Trusted members:_________________________________
___muzzy66, zion187reigneth, Darkness_GR, TRD1JeeZy, 1point21gigawatts, DrBoom, NowHearThis,___
___Chemhaz, Charger, broadz, ~thematt~, keepitreal07, philz, Pulse-R, blanketman, TEGBOY, Damo95,___
_____Pacman, FaBzZz72, devolutionary , The Toad, shaky, MattVIP, Blackfox, Brycestro, KARAFLA_____
__268669, GTi-FTW, fury, Stone, stupidfingers, Tiger, brown202, burgsy, brady123, Morpho, Mr. Drifter____





1 user(s) are reading this topic

0 members, 1 guests, 0 anonymous users