Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Sub too slow?
Mobile Electronics Australia > Mobile Electronics Discussion > Sound Quality Discussion
BlackRain
My sub is slightly out of time with my speakers. Usually it's not noticeable, but when you play faster beat songs, like trance and stuff, you start to notice that the sub-bass hits are slightly slower than the rest. Just the smallest fraction of a second, but when u got beats comin in so frequently, it starts to get muddled up.

My H/U doesn't have time alignment, and neither does my front amp. My sub amp does, but i think it actually slow down the sub and not speed it up.

Other than getting a new sub, are there any ways I can get my sub to respond faster than it's doing now? It's a 12 inch sub (see sig below), and the enclosure is about 1.25 cubic feet.
claf_43
i had the same issue before, i just went for dual 10" subs....

its annoying though i must admit

Any chance that 12 would suit a 1 cubic foot enclosure???? many 12's do thats why im asking
BlackRain
i had a look thru the manual...i don't know if it will suit a 1 cubic foot enclosure.
if it did though, would it make that much of a difference? or would the difference in my sub's response not be worth the hassles of building a new box n stuff for it?
Bassaholic
This is usually a frequency response problem. Basically, either the sub woofer is turned up too loud, or the front speakers are not putting out enough midbass to blend properly with the subs. What are the HPF and LPF set at?
BlackRain
The HPF on the sub amp is set at 80

The LPF on the front amp is set at about 70.

I've got my parametric EQ setting at 50hz, with width of 0.5 and boost of 4db. (If that makes any sense?).
Hutch
Have you tried swapping the phase of the subwoofer relative to the front and rear speakers?
Bassaholic
I think you should play around with the sub level (A common problem, is people have their sub far too loud to have good SQ) as well the LPF and HPF. (lower will usually sound better, but your front speakers will be more likely to exceed their linear xmax at higher volumes)

edit - as Hutch/Cyberpunky have suggested, swapping the polarity/phase *may* help as well.

[ September 23, 2003, 05:31: Message edited by: Bassaholic ]
honour77
Sounds to me like a time delay problem. The sounds from your woofer are taking too long to reach your ear relative to the front speakers so you get that 'slow bass' feeling. Swapping the polarity of your sub or both midbasses together may help, but i doubt it.

Time alignment is your best fix. When i used TA to delay the fronts to match the sub's timing, it was so good that theres no turning back!

Other quick fixes could be to put your sub as close to you as possible. maybe try facing the sub to the front and open the ski hatch or something so your sub has a clear path to you. It might help :
Cyberpunky
Try changing Xover points. Id suggest 70 or lower for LPF and 80-90 for HPF. As hutch suggests, try chnaging phase of sub either via switch if you have one or just swapping pos and neg spkr wires on amp. It may pay to turn boos off on para too.

Just play around and see if anything helps. if everything fails then maybe TA or new sub, but try everythinelse first.

peace
Cyberpunky
Psycronic
If you want to delay the fronts, silicon chip magazine had a kit that could provide up to 20ms delay, it was first used in their prologic decoder and then they released it as a kit on its own.

Try contacting them

ww.siliconchip.com.au

it was the "20ms Delay For Surround Sound Decoders" in the march 1996 issue
Psycronic
it's a sold out issue, but you can get copies of the article

"For readers wanting articles from sold-out issues, (including those from 1987/88) we can supply photostat copies (or tear sheets)
at $8.80 per article (includes GST and p&p).
When supplying photostat articles or back copies, we automatically supply any relevant notes & errata at no extra charge."
Ivestar
Are the subs rear loaded, if so maybe the extra distance it has to travel causes this I didn't have this problem when forward facing but do when rear facing.

In your suggetions, do you mean turn down the gain or the bass level via the head unit?
BlackRain
I've tried facing it rearwards, upwards and forwards. Either way, the difference is negligible...on the fast songs it's still slow..

I'll try playing around with some of the x'overs and the phasing on the amp.

thanks for all ur responses guys..if all else fails..i'm gonna live with it. it's not noticeable on most songs..only those few really fast ones.
Bassaholic
QUOTE
Originally posted by BlackRain:
only those few really fast ones.
I'm just going to point out that you don't mean fast beats per minute, because a fast beat per minute song doesn't neccesarily mean that the attack/delay/sustain/release of the kick drum will be any faster.

[ September 23, 2003, 04:53: Message edited by: Bassaholic ]
BlackRain
?? no idea what that was going on about, pardon my limited understanding...

in laymen's terms...i'm just talkin about techno/trance songs where the beats on the sub just don't go in time with the music cos they're all so closely packed together, making that fraction of a second delay all the more noticeable. that's what happens physically...

in theoretical terms, whatever the underlying technical explanations may be i have no idea.
Bassaholic
QUOTE
Originally posted by BlackRain:

in laymen's terms...i'm just talkin about techno/trance songs where the beats on the sub just don't go in time with the music cos they're all so closely packed together, making that fraction of a second delay all the more noticeable. that's what happens physically...
In that case, I'm not sure that the problem really is the subwoofer adding a delay.

What I'm trying to say is, if the subwoofer was adding a delay, then you would notice that the subwoofer will slow in relation to front stage with every beat - it doesn't matter what the BPM is, because the delay will be relative to your front speakers. - You would tend to notice it more on a quick drum sound.

I mean if the sub took time to respond (that could be fixed by time delaying your front stage), then the sub bass would not be any more muddled up as all of the beats are delayed the same amount - if it was just your sub playing, then you wouldn't notice - you will only notice the difference between the subwoofer and another speaker.
(just for simplification, I am assuming in this example that the subwoofer is delaying every frequency by the same amount...)

------------

I think trying what Hutch/me/Cyberpunky have suggested, may help.

[ September 23, 2003, 05:28: Message edited by: Bassaholic ]
Winno
I had the same problem when I tried a Perfect 12 Infinity in my Sooby wagon. I changed it out for a 10" and the problem disappeared. I too went for two tens in the end and got better results than the one twelve.
Subatomic
yep i get the exact same problem!

only during dance music with really fast bpm. the sub bass hit seems a bit behind the music.

isn't that just because the front speakers are closer so their waves get 2 u a very small fraction of a sec before the bass does??

i think thats all it is. my subs also rearloaded so that wouldn't help

would have thought the best way 2 fix it would be to use a HU with time alignment(sp?)
Spec83
Hmmmm weird...i dont have this prob and i got the same sub that is rear loaded...?

Is it in a sedan... mine is in a hatch so this could explain a difference
Subatomic
yep that would be it. my type S did the same, so its not the subs fault

ah and also, i've only got cheap pioneer splits which lack midbass cause i've got a gutless amp and they're only 5.25"s

[ September 25, 2003, 22:55: Message edited by: SUbatomiC ]
PFX
hi

if it isn't an actual time delay problem i think that it may be a sound level issue.
as we all know, a kick drum starts at a fairly high bass decreasing into a sub bass. the problem you and many others may face is that the sub isn't handling the higher bass frequencies as well as the mid to sub bass; so it seems as though the kick is coming in delayed because the mid and sub bass frequcies occur *slightly* off beat since the kick is mostly high bass. this is especially noticeable if there is a bass boost enabled...
my 2c
regards, alex
BlackRain
Nah I dont have bass boost enabled. Totally flat signal from my H/U.
I drive a two door coupe, and the sub is not that much further from me than my splits. Maybe i just need to eventually look at getting a smaller sub.
But yeah, only on the really fast BPM songs. Usually it sounds schmick. Guess thats the sacrifice of a 12" sub.
s13viper
i have a similar problem ey

its only on the fast beat songs soo its not 2 bad, i can live it it
Dantze
it happens to me when i run my sub on 2 ohm, but when i switched it to 4 or 8 ohm... then its not as loud as before but definitely more accuracy and control...

btw im using 10inch s.stream rubicon.
Rockin
Could that be due to the amps damping level being decreased at lower resistance?

Or do amps still make no difference.....

Please don't flame me, just pulling stuff out of my **** .

EDIT:
Yeah, just realised that I'm now a 1 year+ loyal member! With 357 days.... ummm.... hmmmm...

[ October 09, 2003, 22:00: Message edited by: Rockin ]
Bassaholic
Well it can, but I don't know of any car audio amplifiers that have a damping factor so low that it makes an audible difference. (if you know of one that has a damping factor of less than 20 at its rated impedance, please tell me...)

This problem (assuming you have the rest of the problems sorted out - enclosure design, enclosure position, relative phase, filters and equalizers set correctly etc) is usually caused by the subwoofer being louder than your front stage.. The only way to fix it is by turning the sub down in relation to your front stage.

[ October 10, 2003, 00:03: Message edited by: Bassaholic ]
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2009 Invision Power Services, Inc.
 Runescape