Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: The bet.....
Mobile Electronics Australia > Mobile Electronics Discussion > Sound Quality Discussion
RXimpreza
ok, heres the deal... me and a mate were talking about stereo sound etc. basically there is now $$$ weighting in on the answer to this question.....

mono speakers do they exist and are they any difference to say you regular speaker. (car audio, home hifi i dont really care). if they exist and are different to your regular stereo speakers, how so?? Are they just poor quailty??? althought we agreed on the speaker build quailty generally plays a huge role in A++ sound reproduction, it is the equalize and what not that actually create "stereo sound"???
cheers craig
STIK79
Ummm all speakers are mono... they only produce one channel of sound at any one time yeah?

I'm confused
RXimpreza
oh yeah oh yeah, so me that sweet sweet $$$ biggrin.gif
RTTZ
QUOTE (RXimpreza)
oh yeah oh yeah, so me that sweet sweet $$$ biggrin.gif


Congrats on your win biggrin.gif

How the hell did this question come about? That's got to be an interesting story!

Bye,
Mo
Damon
Err, guys, you all seem a little lost here.

The term 'mono' isn't really supposed to be applied in the way you have used it. In effect, mono stands for singular, and when applied to an audio reference it means when all audio information emanates from one source.

Now, a speaker is a simple device. It can only attempt to reproduce whatever you feed it. If this signal so happens to be a mono signal, then the resulting sound is mono. And yet you could have any number of speakers playing a mono signal simultaneous - like with a public address system for instance.

Also, if you have a regular two channel stereo system and simply disconnect one side - the other does not instantaneously get fed all the information from the disconnected side - does it? So just because one speaker is playing this does not make it a mono speaker, or mono output.

To achieve mono all signals must be converged, and from a discrete stereo source you would need to add left and right to achieve mono.

Cappish?
STIK79
QUOTE (Damon)
Err, guys, you all seem a little lost here.
In effect, mono stands for singular, and when applied to an audio reference it means when all audio information emanates from one source.

Also, if you have a regular two channel stereo system and simply disconnect one side - the other does not instantaneously get fed all the information from the disconnected side - does it? So just because one speaker is playing this does not make it a mono speaker, or mono output.


so if only one speaker is playing - how many sound sources are you listening to? I believe one - and to quote you "mono stands for singular" so infact you do have mono output biggrin.gif

(but yes I get what you mean lol)

So we're not actually lost - just interpretting the menaing of mono differently
RockfordMini
i can't believe u're mate could be so stupid lol
Damon
'sound sources'? I don't get what you mean. Playing back audio through a reproduction system, either done live or playing a recording, means at some stage you'll decide on how the source will be played and through however many speakers. If the source offers more than one discrete channel and you play it back mixed that way - it ain't mono. If all the sound from the recording or performance are combined into one channel, or are recorded onto one channel - that's mono. Ain't that hard to comprehend.
XHELL
I don't think the question negates the need for a bet, any speaker whether it costs $1 or a million dollars can be made sound bad, me - no such thing as a mono "speaker" (unless you mean full range, one driver that covers the entire frequency range?)... I'm confused with the question sorry....
mick007
A speaker is not 'mono' OR 'stereo' a speaker is a piece of equipment that produces sound in what ever form it is recieved. IMO your question is wrong. Because all speakers (note the 's' ) can play either stereo or mono depending on what signal they are given. HOWEVER speaker can only play mono wink.gif
Mick smile.gif
Winno
Mono sound is that which is played back as one channel regardless of how many speakers (left, right, centre, rears, etc) are playing to give the sound.
It can be many channels "down-mixed" in the recording or playback process into one and played back without any difference, one speaker to the other i.e. all playing the same sound at the same time, at the same db level.

Anyway, hopefully you get what I mean.
bmerigan
the previous post has it right.
It's not the speaker that is mono, it is whatever the signal is.

if there's only 1 electrical signal then it is mono, regardless of how many speakers it comes out of.
stereo would be 2 separate signals through 2 separate speakers.
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2008 Invision Power Services, Inc.