Hope that makes sense

I'm obviously on a budget, I have 150wrms availible with an alpine amplifier

Only have heard a Type S and they are quite good actually. In fact i have one for sale with cosmetic damage for a very cheap price

Why are you specifying a 28L enclosure? Shouldnt you be listening to the Sub, chosing the one you like, then building the optimum box for it? I know I would.

Go the response. Good sounding sub in the right box, just don't feed it too much power...

the only reason is, that I allready have a box 28L in voume

I can spend more on the woofer now and I'll build an enclosure later to suite

for 28L your going to have to port it with a 12" sub

The type S ARE good value. I've heard them in and out of car and they sound good for the money.

well i cant comment on the other subs but i have a type S ina 28l in a sedan. sounds ok.. decent enough.. but im planning on upgrading.. damn car audio bug LOL

ps: cant vote for the other subs cus i havnt had experience with em, so this poll is a bit unfair